Microfinance for Beggars?

Yesterday at SCU's event "Transformative Changes Through Science and Technology: The Role for Social Benefit Entrepreneurs" honoring the 2008 Tech Laureates I heard something new. It has made me change my mind. (In the interest of full disclosure, I hereby state that not much changes my mind these days).
Here is the story: I am just back in the US after six weeks in India. A common sight in India is women and children at stop lights- begging. There used to be a time when I would give some change but I have stopped doing it now; doesn't giving them money encourage them? Not much has changed over the years except now they often carry tissue boxes, balloons, magazines, hats, toys etc. to sell. Where did they get the money to buy the stuff? Some tiny children offer entertainment in the from of headstands or juggling or something. "The goods must be stolen; they are just an excuse for begging - whatever" I think. I look away. I can do nothing about this. I feel rotten for a while till I get over it.
Yesterday, I heard Mohammed Yunus talk about Grameen's new program in Dhaka, Bangladesh - "loans to beggars". He thought - why not do something for the beggar? and that's how the program started. They find a beggar and ask one question - at what time in your life did you become a beggar? And then they gave him/her an idea - continue begging, but why not carry some small article to sell- give their "customer" a choice - so as to speak - buy or give charity. If the beggar agreed, they gave an interest free loan with no time set for repayment. Whenever they are read to repay, they can come back to repay. That he said was key. Enablement- a person who tries cannot fail. In fact, they said - take your time to repay. To keep their own costs low, Grameen provides no other service, just trusting the person to come back. Loan amount is $15 flat. So far there is $100K in the program and 11,000 people are not begging anymore. Most others are only part-time beggars and some are successful entrepreneurs.
So next time I am stopped at a light in New Delhi - I will roll down my car window. I may not be in a position to start a loan program but I can buy a box of tissues. Who knows? It might make a difference. Why had I never thought about this before? Why did I assume the goods were stolen? The kids wanted to trick me?
Why? Becuse I still have a lot to learn.

Three Things I learned From Mohammad Yunus

June is graduation month and I got to double dip -my niece's MIT graduation and commencement speech by Mohammad Yunus, in person - all at once.

For me, it wouldn't have mattered what he said- the symbolism of Yunus, with all that he represents, standing at the podium, was enough. By inviting Yunus, MIT faculty is publicly telling its grads, hey look - we know "Each of you has the power to change the world" and this is the direction - a better world for all. Maybe, I don't give enough credit to MIT but I was surprised when I found out. And maybe Yunus was too - because he started his speech with an ad lib that taught me lesson number one.

Relate first and find common ground: he started by thanking MIT for making him feel right at home by bringing on the rain (yes it was pouring out there), just like the monsoons in his native Bangladesh. I could feel the collective tension of a few thousand people dissipate - hey its only water and we are all in it together!

Individual: The "New" Businessman: "money-making is a means, not an end. But for the businessman in the existing theory money-making is both a means and also an end." Businesses have only one metric of success but humans are multifaceted: as people, he said, we are multidimensional but business has one measure- profit. Don't sell yourself short by identifying too much with the current institution of business - it is not only unidimensional, it is flawed. "Poverty is an artificial imposition of the system." Can you change the system? How about a new kind of business with a new kind of metric? "We can easily reformulate the concept of a businessman to bring him closer to a real human being. In order to take into account the multi-dimensionality of real human being we may assume that there are two distinct sources of happiness in the business world 1) maximizing profit, and 2) achieving some pre-defined social objective. Since there are clear conflicts between the two objectives, the business world will have to be made up of two different kinds of businesses --1) profit-maximizing business, and 2) social business. Specific type of happiness will come from the specific type of business"

Action: Break a big problem into bite sized chunks. "Three basic interventions will make a big difference in the existing system : a) broadening the concept of business by including "social business" into the framework of market place, b) creating inclusive financial and health care services which can reach out to every person on the planet, c) designing appropriate information technology devices, and services for the bottom-most people and making them easily available to them."

Do read the whole speech. His ideas about financial instruments (dow jones for social businesses, partnership with Danone, Intel.. make it all sound not only possible but probable.

Go Grads!